Every module button action plays the chime, and the speaker hisses for a few seconds after it. I logged the bar’s speaker output while pressing:
Button
Output open
Dot Key
4.8 s
VivoCube button
4.7 s
That’s the chime plus Android’s 3-second output standby delay on the bar (Standby delay ns=3000000000). The static stops at the moment the output closes. The amplifier stays powered while any audio output is open and hisses even at media volume 0.
This isn’t limited to the chime. My custom screensaver app plays a muted video stream, and while it ran the speaker hissed continuously, even with media volume at 0. The only fix was to have the app open no audio output at all. Any app that holds audio open, even silently, makes the bar hiss for as long as it runs.
Suggested fixes:
Mute or power down the amplifier whenever no audio is actually playing (drive the amp’s enable/mute from output standby).
With the VivoCube attached, I hear a faint, pulsing static coming from the cube itself, even while the bar’s speaker output is closed. Removing the cube stops it.
I’ve forwarded your feedback about the hissing noise and your suggestions to the relevant team. They will test the issue, assess whether the proposed solution is feasible, and check whether VivoCube is affected by a similar problem. I’ll let you know once we have any findings.
I’ve also noted your suggestion to add an option to turn the notification sound on or off, and I’ll bring it up at a future feature discussion.
If you have any other suggestions, please feel free to share them with us. We truly appreciate your feedback!
Thanks Vicky. I ran a few more tests that should help the team:
1. The hiss is the amplifier’s own noise floor, so volume can’t fix it. I played pure digital silence (all-zero samples) through the speaker and switched the codec’s analog gain (headphone gain) between 7 and 0. The hiss sounded the same at both. The speaker amp’s enable pin (gpio-spk, SPK) already follows the output: it switches on when the PCM opens and off when it closes. So the hiss lasts exactly as long as the output stays open.
2. A shorter output standby fixes most of it. With ro.audio.flinger_standbytime_ms=200 (the default is 3000 ms), a button chime keeps the speaker output open 2.0 s instead of 4.7 s, and the chime still plays normally. Adding this to the system build.prop would be a one-line change.
3. The chime file has a long silent tail.key_alert.mp3 is 1.83 s long, but the tone is only about 0.5 s; the remaining 1.3 s is a slow fade (from about −27 dB down to −94 dB), and the amp hisses all the way through it. Trimming the file to about 0.5 s, together with the shorter standby, would bring the hiss after each press down to roughly 0.2 s.
4. Measured with the SenseCube. I used the SenseCube V2’s sound level readings (about 10 per second) as a meter, with the cube next to the bar. I alternated the speaker off, on with silence at full analog gain, and on with silence at minimum gain, four times each. All three read about 33 dB, the same as the room. As a check, a 1 kHz test tone at −40 dBFS raised the reading by 3 dB, while one at −60 dBFS didn’t register. So the hiss is quieter than normal room noise, but you can clearly hear it when you sit at the desk. The bar’s own microphones didn’t pick it up either.
An option to turn the chime off would still be welcome for anyone who wants no hiss at all.
Thank you so much for sharing your feedback. It’s extremely valuable to our R&D team, and I’ve passed it along. I’ve also reiterated your suggestion to add an option to turn sound effects on or off. The team is taking it seriously, and we hope to add this feature soon.
I’d also like to commend you for your dedication. Your expertise and the care you put into testing and exploring the product are truly impressive—and inspiring to us. Thank you again for your support. We look forward to hearing more of your feedback!